An honest, detailed comparison of Yondr pouches and LockedIn's software-based approach to phone-free schools — covering cost, effectiveness, logistics, and real-time monitoring.
Yondr pouches have been the most recognized phone-free school solution for years. But as schools gain experience with pouches, a growing number are looking for alternatives that address the logistical headaches and blind spots that come with a hardware-based approach. Here's how the two solutions compare.
How Each Solution Works
Yondr Pouches
Yondr provides magnetically-sealed neoprene pouches. Students place their phones inside the pouch at the start of the school day, and the pouch is locked with a magnetic seal. At the end of the day, students unlock their pouches at designated unlocking stations. The phone is physically inaccessible throughout the day.
LockedIn
LockedIn is an app installed on student phones that uses OS-level device locking to lock the device during school hours. When a student enters the campus geofence during school hours, they receive a notification to lock in. The phone is locked at the software level, and administrators can monitor compliance in real time through a dashboard.
Cost Comparison
Factor
Yondr
LockedIn
Per-student cost
$25–30/year
Contact us
Replacement costs
$25–30 per broken pouch
$0 — it's software
Hardware required
Pouches + unlocking bases
None
Staff time (daily)
15–30 min distribution/collection
0 minutes — fully automated
For a school of 1,000 students, Yondr pouches cost $25,000–30,000 per year plus replacement costs. LockedIn costs significantly less with zero hardware to replace.
Enforcement Effectiveness
The biggest issue schools report with Yondr pouches is circumvention. Students have discovered that they can place a decoy phone (or an old phone) in the pouch and keep their real phone in their pocket. Since pouches provide no visibility into what's actually inside them, staff have no way to verify compliance without physically opening each pouch.
LockedIn addresses this by catching every common bypass trick — fake devices, student hotspot sharing, Bluetooth workarounds like AirPods, Apple Watches, and Meta glasses, screen mirroring, split-screen attempts, and more. Every attempt triggers an instant alert to administrators.
Real-Time Monitoring and Reporting
Yondr provides no data. Once a pouch is sealed, you have zero visibility into whether the policy is actually working. You can't generate compliance reports, you can't identify repeat offenders, and you have no data to show your school board or state.
LockedIn provides a real-time admin dashboard that shows every student's status — locked in, grace period, or non-compliant. Compliance reports are generated automatically and delivered to your inbox daily and weekly. This is increasingly important as states begin requiring documented proof of enforcement.
The Verdict
Yondr pouches were a pioneering first-generation solution that proved phone-free policies can work. But they come with real trade-offs: no monitoring, no data, high replacement costs, and daily staff burden.
LockedIn represents the next generation — software-based, data-driven, and operationally effortless. It costs less and provides more visibility.
Ready to see the difference? Get started at your school.
Related Reading